Can two contrasting answers to a one answer question both be right?
At church yesterday an Indian guy called Peter shared his testimony of how he was adopted by American parents after his father had had to put him and his brother up for adoption after his mother died [two of the six children were put up for adoption as the father thought they would get a better life that way].
Before that his American parents-to-be had already had four children of their own, and due to medical reasons could not have any more, but the mom believed that she had two more children. But she wanted the dad to come to the same decision. One night he went to a church meeting that she was supposed to go to in which a missionary from India spoke and he came home and announced to his wife that he thought they had the capacity for two more children. So they started the process of investigation.
During that time two different sets of people were praying for them and believed God told them the ages of their children. The one couple told them their children would be 6 and 8 years old and the second couple told them they would be 11 and 13 years old. [Now this is going to be a tough one for God to make happen, right? Wrong.] Peter and his brother were 6 and 8 years old when their American parents met them for the first time… and they were 11 and 13 when they arrived in Americaland to be joined to their new family.
DOES THAT NOT BLOW YOU AWAY? It really should. The ‘nah, coincidence’ people are going to have a tough time with that one. And it would have been great to be able to hear the parent’s account of the story because before you know the end to it, you hear the different ages and your initial thought is, ‘Hm, i wonder which one got it wrong.’ But no, God is faithful and it is stories like this which just help prove it. We serve the God of the absolutely impossible.
This reminds me of an ex convict marching up to a national leader and declaring to him, “Let my people go!” Or a nation marching around a city seven times and blowing some musical instruments and shouting and seeing the walls collapse on the city. It reminds me of a shepherd boy with a catty and five little stones facing down a giant of a military man or another little kid with a severely reduced army taking on an army, described as many as the grains of sand on a beach, with 300 people armed with torches and trumpets.
And so on… and it is not the miracle that is as attractive as the love and power of an involved God that it points towards. Something about trusting in the Lord, with all of our hearts, and leaning not on our own understanding. In all our ways acknowledging Him and watching as He makes our paths straight. [paraphrase of Proverbs 3.5-6]



Brett, i’ve personally had similar amazing “words of knowledge” experiences. For instance, knowing very obscure details about the lives of total strangers when I was evangelising. And I would have felt the same way about it as you. These days I tend towards being one of those “nah, coincidence people”. Or alternatively the “human minds and connections and the physical world they are part of are awe inspiring and fun to try and explain” people. . I personally think this world is incredible. And remarkable things happen, some of which can be explained, some of which can’t. But even when remarkable things happen they aren’t proof of a particular world view. Miraculous things happen to hindus, muslims, JW’s, after prayer and not after prayer as they do for Christians. It’s true. And they see these things as proof of their world view which wouldn’t included the bits about Jesus being God. Remarkable things happen even to atheists possibly because (a) their alive, or (b) God is trying to get through to their stupid heads for the umpteenth time but they really, really don’t want to see (smiley face wink here, written rather than, um, pictured, to avoid offending your anti-smiley sensibilities. Oh stuff it 😉
Personally, I’m saying all this reluctantly, because I’m really not wanting to steal away anyone’s joy or personal explanations or faith. For that reason I’ve not wanted to go much beyond saying actually, despite the wonderful story, and it is a wonderful story, I’m still not convinced that it is proof of anything. You often speak about the need for honest communication, and I agree with you. Live and let live shouldn’t involve hiding our opinions under a bushel.
absolutely on the honesty thing which is why i must warn you that the grandma police are probably on their way now with the rubber mallets for a class A ‘their/they’re’ offence… but ja, i still contend that it takes more faith to believe there is no God than there is one [whether or not it is the Christian God is a whole ‘nother step in the process] and i would hate to find out i believed something that turned out to be false and so definitely not a blind belief but one that is tested regularly and one that definitely meets up with a lot of questions and doubts and not surables from time to time… and each ‘coincidence’ by itself would not measure up and even just relying on a whole big bag of ‘coincidences’ would not either but for me it’s a combination of a whole bunch of things that when put together still manage to convince me that Jesus is the way, truth and life as He claims to be…
Hey Brett, I’m not suggesting that you don’t test your faith in a way that satisfies your own criteria. Likewise I test my own. But your post suggests that your story should be proof for everybody: “DOES THAT NOT BLOW YOU AWAY? It really should. The ‘nah, coincidence’ people are going to have a tough time with that one”. It isn’t proof for me. I could tell you all the reasons why, but I don’t think that would be appropriate. It would seem like I was trying to tear down something good, and I don’t either want to do that nor appear to be doing that. I just wanted to point out that people have different criteria as proof.
Something that you might find hard to accept is that my own path to agnostic atheism (which is not an active belief in the absence of a god/God, but the lack of active belief in a god/God) was necessary for my own growth as a person. I know atheists who could well benefit from converting to Christianity in order to grow as human beings.
Peace
David
ps Their Behind Me! (the grandma police, I mean)
Thank you